Presidents of the Underhill Society of America

Presidents of the Underhill Society of America include:
 * William Wilson Underhill (1892–1898)
 * Estelle Skidmore Doremus (1898–1905)
 * Col. John Torboss Underhill (1905–1924)
 * Francis Jay Underhill (1924-1932)
 * Willard Underhill Taylor (1932–1940)
 * John Garret Underhill, Sr. (1940–1946)
 * Irving Underhill (1946–1950)
 * Robert Feeks Underhill (1950–1954)
 * John Garrett Underhill, Jr. (1954–1956)
 * Charles Alonzo Underhill (1956–1968)
 * George Townsend Underhill, Sr. (1968–1973)
 * Le Grand Underhill (1974–1975)
 * Thelma Weeks Powell (1975–1979)
 * Hary Macy, Jr. (1979–1985)
 * Andrew Mitchell Underhill, Jr. (1985–1987)
 * Robert G. Pope (1987–1995)
 * Richard W. Decker (1995–1996)
 * N. Robert Underhill (1996–1998)
 * George Townsend Underhill, Jr. (1998–2003)
 * Carl J. Underhill (2003–2010)
 * Robert L. Underhill (2010–2011)
 * Jay B. Tucker (2011–present)